Dominique Davis’ Falling for the Mark released on April 11, 2023.
Many thanks to the author for providing an early e-ARC in exchange for an honest review!
Dominique Davis makes her fiction debut with Falling for the Mark, a messy sapphic romance that tackles grief and human connection through characters that come from near-opposite walks of life.
Nicole and Maya, a mother-daughter con duo, set their sights on Eric Hayes, a wealthy, widowed doctor as their next mark following an online relationship. Packing up and moving to Philadelphia is all a part of the con, a way to get into the house, create the perfect picture of a relationship, and convince Eric to propose to Nicole. All is well and good until Eric’s daughter, Kennedy, learns of the entire affair, just days before the duo are set to arrive.
Blindsided not only by her father’s secret relationship, but the fact that two strangers will be moving into their home in a matter of days is enough to set her off. Anger has always come easily to Kennedy, but she’s sure that there’s an ulterior motive somewhere, and makes it her mission to learn about Nicole and whatever past she may be hiding. Enter Maya: a product of her upbringing, Maya allegedly lives for the con – that is, until she meets Eric, who appears to be a genuinely kind man, and his daughter, Kennedy, who quickly becomes more than just the daughter of a mark.
Although Davis alternates between Kennedy and Maya as main POV characters while Nicole and Eric’s relationship heads toward marriage in the background (a necessity for the con to work), Kennedy is easily the star of the show. Her fierce, stubborn personality makes for a great catalyst that adds much needed emotional tension to an otherwise simple plot.
Full of pent-up anger, not to mention years’ worth of buried grief, Kennedy pushes back against Nicole and Maya, their attempts to win her favor ignored, criticized, and laughed off until Maya provides unexpected comfort and emotional support following a handful of immature, if difficult situations, including a drunken fall in the pool and a beer pong bet gone wrong.
From then on, a slow relationship unfolds, one that is sweet, wholesome, and thoroughly unexpected on both sides. Kennedy, closed off due to her grief, slowly opens up, trusting Maya even as she questions Nicole’s motives. For someone sworn off of love, Kennedy falls hard, Maya a source of gentle comfort and understanding, one that coaxes her to embrace her emotions, which include the trauma and unhealed grief of her mother’s death.
Little does Kennedy know that she is also healing Maya. In an attempt to be civil (and supportive), Kennedy encourages Maya to join the local theater group after Maya expresses interest in acting, having participated (briefly) in high school plays. Something that was initially an outlet for gaining the skills necessary to succeed as a partner in the family con game becomes a source of genuine joy and friendship, wherein little connections and displays of compassion push Maya to see the error of her ways, causing her to question her morality and stake in the game. It’s not quite enough to justify her (or Nicole’s) decisions, but it does go a long way in making the mother-daughter duo a bit more likable.
While the novel has very sweet undertones, and there were a few moments between Kennedy and Maya that I genuinely enjoyed, including their time in a charming little indie bookshop, and a sentimental gift shared between the two later on, their relationship (and the overarching plot of the novel) felt unfinished. Trust is broken and regained (for Kennedy and Eric) quite easily, when Kennedy inevitably learns the truth behind Nicole and Maya’s dealings with her father.
Add in Kennedy’s half-baked attempt at an investigation, not to mention the backstory (or lackthereof, aside from a petty revenge plot against Maya’s father, and all men, due to his abandonment) regarding Nicole and Maya’s cons, and things come across as a little too simplistic. Any attempt to add tension or emotional impact is ultimately undermined, or brought up short, or simply forgotten.
While Davis introduced a fascinating premise in the idea of a mother-daughter con duo brought down by unexpected romance, the execution fell a little short for my tastes, not just in the relative ease with which conflict is resolved, but in the foundation of the story, which is written with very clear, concise, and simple statements. While the narrative style makes for a very quick read, it does come off feeling a bit flat and emotionless with very little character definition or voice. While Kennedy’s grief, and eventual healing, do spark an emotional response and are handled pretty well, I longed to see more of Maya’s inner turmoil, which borders on contradictory at times.
A personal, and perhaps subjective, qualm for me was the way in which Maya’s demisexuality was handled. I loved seeing that representation; but, because we see so little emotion in the characters’ narration, including internal monologue, and the writing style itself is simplistic in nature, I did have questions about her feelings in regard to sex, physical touch, and attraction. The representation is there; Maya is demisexual, and her feelings and viewpoints are valid experiences, especially when it comes to her slow-burning relationship with Kennedy. But, I did wonder if the con life had any impact on her mentally, as it required her to openly flirt and engage others in suggestive, intimate activity, that, while never quite reaching anything penetrative, did often include physical touch and kissing.
For someone under the ace umbrella, intimate physical touch and sex have the potential to be very difficult and may or may not have discomfort associated with it depending on personal preference and emotions. Can you have sex without sexual attraction? Absolutely and unequivocally. It’s very likely that Maya simply considered physical intimacy and touch with their marks to be nothing but an act, a necessary part of the con. However, we don’t really see her consider or respond to her role other than the straight, cold, simple facts of her encounters. Is this a coping mechanism or form of distance? Due to the narrative shortcomings in style, it is difficult to tell. Perhaps it is less a question of her sexuality and more a question of the personal and emotional tolls that the cons had on her, but I did feel that something was missing when it came to Maya’s view on being a sexual pawn in the con game, especially when her demisexuality is taken into consideration.
On the topic of sexuality and physical touch, while Maya and Kennedy’s relationship is a slow burn that is full of charm and sweet gestures, sex between them felt a little rough, in large part due to the narrative style. There are a handful of steamy scenes, but passion isn’t always at the forefront, at least as far as narration goes. Much like the characters’ internal thoughts and feelings, the physical aspect of their relationship seemed to lack emotion and come off as a bit too straightforward as well, as if the characters were enjoying themselves but simply going through the motions. I never truly felt the chemistry between them beyond somewhat vague comments, which left me feeling a little disappointed in their relationship arc and intimacy in general.
There also seemed to be a deep-seated hatred for all men, with no real reasoning behind it. One can infer that, perhaps, Nicole and Maya have trouble forming relationships with men because they were abandoned, but I wasn’t a big fan on how the marks were all portrayed as inherently sexual beings with bad intentions. While it seems that Nicole and Maya tended to look for these features in a potential target (almost every con hinges upon infidelity, with the mark eventually attempting to sleep with Maya), it left a bad impression for the reader, especially when the topic of clothing was brought up. While Eric is shown to be a great, if somewhat bland, father and man, a number of generalizations are made that imply that most men are disgusting and have no morals when it comes to sexualizing women.
Eric may be more of a stand-up guy than I originally envisioned, but deep down, he is still a warm-blooded man. There are few men that have the willpower to resist a young gorgeous woman throwing themselves onto them. Eric won’t be any different. […] Maya tried on clothes that Nicole had bought for her. It was classic attire that was typically deemed inappropriate to wear around men. Which included shorts, skirts, sheer blouses, cut-outs, and skin-revealing dresses.
– excerpt from Dominique Davis’ Falling for the Mark
The idea that simple items, such as skirts and shorts, are some how inappropriate to wear around men really didn’t sit well with me personally. It’s an idea that is perpetualized in society – school dress codes, for example – but fuck, if it was unsettling to read. In the same vein, I was absolutely baffled by the idea that Nicole had to con men for money in order to make ends meet. We’re given very little background on this, but I simply couldn’t understand the reasoning behind it, nor could I understand why a mother would want to put her daughter in sexual situations, especially as a young adult. We’re never really told why the con life became a primary source of income, but we are told that it was the only option. Even if you were to suspend disbelief in favor of the narrative (it is fiction after all, and anything could happen), Nicole’s choices didn’t sit well with me, and I would have loved to have more insight into her professional life and the personal decisions behind it.
All in all, Falling for the Mark is a short, simple sapphic read that has its fair share of ups and downs. With an interesting premise, and a handful of sweet, wholesome moments, it will certainly appeal to romance readers looking for a quick read that doesn’t take itself too seriously. While it does have shortcomings for those looking for a more emotive narrative style and depth, Davis does a good job tackling themes of grief, trauma, and belonging, while setting an intriguing premise for a sequel to follow for Nicole.
Leave a Reply